Choosing a brake pad

Red_Bean_Bun

Well-Known Member
Today was asked by a bro on the forum which brake pad is a good match for his ride. His ride is a F30 and though the sensor hasn’t hit the threshold, we thought it’s a good idea to get it changed next week.

So I dug up my old notes from way back to have a look at a couple of major factors to consider when choosing brake pads – Friction co efficient and temperature before fade. There is another factor which is initial bite (which is not big on my mind) but this is the factor that illustrates the behavior of the at its initial contact when the braking begins. So when the initial bite rating is higher than the average friction co efficient – Expect some jerking action and a “sudden” deceleration before it gradually stops. Most OEM pads have a higher initial bite.

So before you choose a pad you need to understand how this works. SAE has a standard for rating the friction co efficiency of these pad materials. It looks like this -

Friction Coefficient Code

View attachment 58324

The friction co efficient D has the least braking power while H has the highest braking power. However, before you going out to buy the pad with the highest rated co efficient you need to understand the tradeoffs –

- The higher the code, the higher the wear acceleration on your rotors
- The higher the code the higher the operating temperature. These pads can go up to a very high temperature
before it fades. This also means that it needs to go up to a higher temperature before it become efficient.
- While the pads are cold, it makes a heck of a lot of noise till it warms up
- And it won’t be as bite as well while its cold as well


And that is why you need to drive fast to get these G rated pads and above to work well – Like on a track.

Here’s some data of what the characteristics of the pads are –

OEM

- examples: Mintex, Textar
- cF=0.30-0.40
- max temp before fade: 315-370 Celsius

Street Performance

- examples: Hawk HPS, EBC Greenstuff, EBC Redstuff, Porterfield R4-S, Axxis Ultimate
- cF=0.41-0.45
- max temp before fade: 370-537 celsius

Light Track Pad

- examples: Hawk HP+, Ferodo DS-2000, EBC Yellowstuff
- cF=0.46-0.49
- max temp before fade: 482-593 celsius

Track Pad

- examples: Ferodo DS-2500
- cF=0.50-0.55
- max temp before fade: 593-704

Race Pad

- examples: Ferodo DS-3000, Hawk Blue 9012, Hawk Black, EBC Bluestuff, Porterfield R4
- cF=0.56-0.68 (depends on specific race application)
- max temp before fade: 704+ celsius (depends on specific race application)

Brembo have a cF between 0.4 (340 celsius) to 0.63 (390 celsius)

Some interesting information –

- Pads that can go up to 1648 celsius will start to glow. These are typically Carbon brake pads
- All Pads will have a print at the edge to give you the rating. This is especially so for SAE DOT compliant pads
- 100% Steel on Steel rotors have a cF of 0.25
- So some E rated pads have a marginal level of stopping power more than using a piece of Steel as a brake pad.
- F rated pads are the minimum to be considered a Performance Brake Pad

View attachment 58323

So based on what he was driving (F30) and driving style - He chose the EBC Greenstuff.
 
Re: Choosing a brake pad

EBC Greenstuff squeek?

9/10 aftermarket (non oem) brake pads squeeks ... either ngee-ngee or click-click sound
 
Re: Choosing a brake pad

Any writeup on rotor?
 
Re: Choosing a brake pad

Mine is on Hawk HPS with OEM calipers - no squeaks or clicks.

Must bed in properly (squeaks) and use the correct FMSI code for fitment (clicks).

wt_know;1061649 said:
EBC Greenstuff squeek?

9/10 aftermarket (non oem) brake pads squeeks ... either ngee-ngee or click-click sound
 
Choosing a brake pad

wt_know;1061649 said:
EBC Greenstuff squeek?

9/10 aftermarket (non oem) brake pads squeeks ... either ngee-ngee or click-click sound


No audible squeaks for mine. A good workshop will do proper bedding, which should eliminate most of the mice.

Note - perhaps my exhaust also drowned out all other sounds... lol
 
Re: Choosing a brake pad

will HAwk HPS (blue) pads squeak, yeeak, ngouk, ngeak, etc... on brembo cross drilled rotors?
 
Re: Choosing a brake pad

Had HPS on brembo cross drilled previously. No problems if installed properly - like don't put anything upside down .... Clean the parts and look for arrows.
 
Re: Choosing a brake pad

FMSI is a set of standards ...... Along with DOT.

The FMSI standard I was referring to is the FMSI pad shape.

http://zeckhausen.com/Brembo/Consumables.htm#Pads

So for each caliper (and in this link's example - it's Brembo) - notice the FMSI pad shape code. Use that to make sure fitment is correct. Some WS still use tracing paper and faxing it to distributor for ordering replacements.
 
Re: Choosing a brake pad

While shopping for brake pads and BBK, i came across one of the most honest qriteup by a brake manufacturer (Stoptech)

Your brakes do not stop your car. Your tires do stop the car. So while changes to different parts of the brake system may affect certain characteristics or traits of the system behavior, using stickier tires is ultimately the only sure-fire method of decreasing stopping distances.”

However, there’s more to the story. Yes the tires stop the car, but improper brake balance can make a complete mess out of even the best components
.


White Paper - Brake Bias and Performance- Why Brake Balance Matters
 
Re: Choosing a brake pad

and that's why I am on Stoptech.
 
Re: Choosing a brake pad

Hawks HP's very good n no sound n good bit.

Easy warm up too
 
Re: Choosing a brake pad

EBC as well....

No brake dust!
 
Re: Choosing a brake pad

christopher ngo;1087264 said:
What about ferodo ?

Hi, we are talking about brake pads, not Lord of the Rings.

Thanks


And the last I remember, Mr Frodo succeeded in throwing the Ring into Mount Doom
 

Latest posts

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
82,745
Messages
1,019,304
Members
77,693
Latest member
abc88bar

Latest posts

Back
Top