Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

ac323

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Moderator
The grandson of the founder of Shaw Organisation, who was charged with paying an underaged girl for sex in April, asked for an early plea to be taken.

This means that 41-year-old Howard Shaw will decide whether or not to plead guilty.

Former Singapore Environment Council (SEC) executive director Howard Shaw was among the 48 men who were earlier charged with paid sex with a 17-year-old girl.

He is now represented by a team of lawyers led by Mr Harpreet Singh Nehal, a senior counsel from WongPartnership.

In a statement to the media, his lawyers raised the issue of Shaw's charge, which falls under Section 376B of the Penal Code, which is an "absolute liability offence" under Singapore law.

This means that the accused would be deemed to have committed the offence - even though there's no intent.

Under the Section 377D, a mistake on the age of the minor is also not a defence.

The lawyers pointed out that under Section 376B, the courts has "an extremely wide sentencing discretion, ranging from a fine to a maximum jail sentence of seven years".

Section 376B states that any person who obtains for consideration the sexual services of a person, who is under 18 years of age, shall be punished with imprisonment for a term which may extend to seven years, or with fine, or with both.

They said this case raises important questions of law and public policy, as to how the courts should approach their wide sentencing discretion under this section.

They said the court's decision on the questions of law and policy raised in this case will have significant ramifications, not just for Shaw but for the other men who have been charged with the same offences, or who may in future face a charge under this section, or related sections, of the Penal Code.

Hence, they have sought and obtained a hearing on 27 June to address these issues with the court.

A former executive director of operations at UBS Investment Bank, who has been charged with two counts of having paid sex with the same girl, will be contesting the charges.

40-year-old Swiss expatriate Juerg Buergin will be back in court on 3 July.

Juerg, who is currently unemployed, allegedly paid the girl for sex in late 2010 and early 2011.

He is currently out on a S$15,000 bail.

His lawyer, Mr Selva K. Naidu, commented that his client is "reasonably okay".

The former principal of Pei Chun Public School, Lee Lip Hong, was the first man to be convicted in the online vice ring case. He was sentenced to nine weeks' jail in April, and was released on 8 June for good behaviour after serving six weeks behind bars.
 
Re: Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

fined 1000?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Re: Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

Should have tried getting someone old to "TAHAN" the conviction first!
 
Re: Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

wt_know;836032 said:
fined 1000?

This one so elite, must send a jialat jialat strong strong signal to the community.

Fine of $100, not a cent more.

We have to let them know that the elite will be taken care of, no matter the cost.
 
Re: Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

I say FINE but no jail.

Ai bet mai?
 
Re: Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

DrK;836102 said:
I say FINE but no jail.

Ai bet mai?

Actually the timing is not right for him.... After WW saga, they may not want to risk this by awarding a $100 fine
 
Re: Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

If I remember correctly, Howard Shaw was represented by Wendell Wong of D&N, who was a DPP. Anyone knows why he changed his lawyer?
 
Re: Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

Maybe they asked him to plead guilty like the principal? Keke
 
Re: Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

maybe he piak the gal much earlier, in 2006
and penal code or whatever is more relaxed then

so also just 1k
law minister will personally explain why too
 
Re: Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

storm in a teacup leh, cos no victim both win win, so best to let him go with a fine plus community service, say order him to organise the BMW charity drive and start the ball rolling with $1000 donation...
 
Re: Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

joshdway;836139 said:
maybe he piak the gal much earlier, in 2006
and penal code or whatever is more relaxed then

so also just 1k
law minister will personally explain why too

wow, how old would she be then? :lol2:
 
Re: Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

DrK;836102 said:
I say FINE but no jail.

Ai bet mai?

....Fine ...& .... maybe 1 week ....White collar enclosure....

...still got such thing anot?? Last time in Queensway remand...:chinese:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Re: Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

Shame to shaw empire.... pui...
 
Re: Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

I am very sure this is not the only such case of its kind. But why the high media exposure over this particular case??? i know it involves quite a fair bit of ppl, including educators and elites. But I still find it very strange why only this case. confirm got many many unreported cases.....
 
Re: Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

delrosa81;836200 said:
I am very sure this is not the only such case of its kind. But why the high media exposure over this particular case??? i know it involves quite a fair bit of ppl, including educators and elites. But I still find it very strange why only this case. confirm got many many unreported cases.....

I am sure the authority tried their very best to cover up this saga especially with the real big shots still unname, and only bo bian then surface. More of propaganda than anything else.
Perhaps the main cast is not even out yet. Where's the third batch of offenders?
Still in negotiation with ah gong?
 
Re: Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

3rd batch to be released in 6 years time?
 
Re: Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

wt_know;836521 said:
3rd batch to be released in 6 years time?

and all ganna fined $1000 each?
 
Re: Howard Shaw to decide whether or not to plead guilty

sszone;836148 said:
wow, how old would she be then? :lol2:

no problem for our law minister

he confirm can find good 'above board' reasoning
mai doubt his first class talent and his multi dollar salary
 

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
82,766
Messages
1,019,405
Members
78,670
Latest member
oxbett2com
Back
Top